MorningStar's Mushroom Lover's Burgers are definitely for mushroom lovers only

Posted on Apr 4th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
 

It was with trepidation that I reviewed Gardenburger's Portabella Burgers last week, because I am not a fan of mushrooms. But I ended up actually loving them, which was a surprise to say the least. So I was almost looking forward to reviewing MorningStar's Mushroom Lover's Burgers, thinking that I may actually be starting to like mushrooms. Eating one of these patties jolted me back to reality.

Gardenburger may say that their Portabella is "the shroomiest burger off the shelf," but they have nothing, and I mean nothing, on the MorningStar's Mushroom Lover's burgers. These burgers taste like friggin' mushrooms. Having spent my life avoiding mushrooms, I didn't find eating this alt-burger very pleasurable. But if you're a fungal fanatic, you'll probably be in heaven.

The hardest part about this review is reviewing it as if I like mushrooms. I mean, who wants to read a review about a mushroom burger written by a guy who doesn't like mushrooms? So it is as my mushroom-loving alter-ego, Finneus Fungal III, that I will review these shroom patties and give them 4 stars.

To sum up the review: If you're not a mushroom lover, stay away from these. If you love mushrooms, run out and get a box.

Tags: burger

Litelife's Smart Bacon

Posted on Mar 31st, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Lightlife
 

Bacon is a unique-tasting and difficult item to mimic I would imagine. MorningStar did a pretty good job. Their alt-bacon actually tastes like slightly burnt bacon (the best kind). Unfortunately, Litelife's Smart Bacon isn't as successful.

Smart Bacon does look a heckuva lot more like actual bacon than MorningStar's Play-Doh-looking bacon. But this alt-bacon's looks belie its taste. Smart Bacon just doesn't taste much like bacon. There's not much more to it than that.

Tags: breakfast

Wildwood's Original Tofu-Veggie Burgers

Posted on Mar 28th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Wildwood
 

Wildwood's Original Tofu-Veggie Burgers are impressive in size, and they are rare in that they don't come frozen. Sadly, both of these distinctions do nothing to overcome the fact that these are pretty boring alt-burgers.

The Tofu-Veggie Burgers are considerably bigger than your average patty. Most alt-meat boxes come with four 2.25-2.5 oz. patties. The Tofu-Veggie patties are an impressive 3.25 oz. each. That's a full 30-44% bigger. Unfortunately, patty size doesn't affect taste. In the case of these patties, it's just 44% more blandness.

The taste, texture, and appearance of these patties reminded me a lot of quiche. But what makes quiche good is what you put in the quiche. Without tasty ingredients, you're left with just watered-down eggs, which is not very appetizing. It was pretty much the same with the Tofu-Veggie Burgers. The main ingredients in the Tofu-Veggie Burgers - yellow onion, carrot, kale, and garlic powder - did nothing to help save the taste. At least I was full after eating one of the patties, I guess.

I will definitely try Wildwood's other Tofu-Veggie Burgers, but I just hope they have more taste than the Original.

Tags: burger

Quorn's Chik'n Patties

Posted on Mar 6th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Quorn
 

After I survived eating a Naked Chik'n Cutlet last month, I was hesitant about volunteering for another game of Russian roulette with my organs. But I am a soldier, and it is my duty to review all alt-meat products for the greater good. So I loaded up my gun with a Quorn Chik'n patty and fired away.

After having previously chewed my way through the dull-tasting Naked Chik'n Cutlets, I was hoping that Quorn's Chik'n patties benefited from the universal law of "bread it, and it will be good." It seems Quorn has found a way to break even this universal constant. Even the breading on these alt-chicken patties was tasteless. Which forced me to focus more on the un-chicken-like tasting "meat" of the patty. Quorn: 0, Bland: 2.

On the plus side, however, I did survive another Quorn meal with no rashes or paralysis. And these patties are legitimately larger than your average patty. But "bland" is a bit like infinity - more bland is still just plain bland.

I was surprised again, however, to discover that Quorn packaged their food without plastic, leaving the cutlets with only a thin layer of pervious, folded cardboard to protect them. Shouldn't this be illegal? Maybe it is, and those who try and report Quorn to the authorities are the ones that mysteriously get dysentery. If that's true, I guess I'd better shut up. I like my lower intestine blood-free.

Tags: chicken

Gardenburger's Portabella

Posted on Feb 28th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Gardenburger
 

It was duty alone that compelled me to pick up a box of Gardenburger's Portabella veggie burgers, because I am not a fan of mushrooms. I don't have anything against my fungal friends, I'm just fairly indifferent when it comes to their taste and texture.

On their site, Gardenburger had this to say about the Portabella:

"A savory whole grain burger made from fine portabella mushrooms with mozzarella cheese, wild rice, fresh onions and rolled oats. The shroomiest burger off the shelf."

I love that first sentence. That second sentence makes me nervous.

No one was happier than I was, however, when I actually cooked up one of these alt-burgers. I fried one up in a pan with some onions, and just slapped both on a bun. It was one of the best veggie burgers I've had so far. They didn't taste "shroomy" at all. Just damn tasty.

The Portabella tastes very similar to Gardenburger's California burger but with a more "meaty" flavor due to the shrooms. I'm actually starting to think I would enjoy any alt-burger that had rice, oats, and onions as main ingredients. Every veggie burger I've had so far with "The Trinity" has been very good.

I will definitely continue to pick up boxes of these when I'm at the store.

Tags: burger

Quorn's Naked Chik'n Cutlet

Posted on Feb 11th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Quorn
 

I was happy to see a new brand of alt-meat products, Quorn, pop-up in the freezer the last time I was at the store, but I wasn't holding much hope for their Naked Chik'n Cutlets. The last thing I want to see alt-meat companies do is create "naked" items. Chicken is hard enough to mimic, but when you don't have the all-important herb- and spice-infused breading to help you out, you're pretty much left with a flavorless slab of protein.

In the case of the Quorn's alt-chicken products, they use Mycoprotein.

According to Quorn's website:

"Myco" is Greek for "fungi." The mycoprotein comes from Fusarium venenatum, which was originally discovered growing in a field in Buckinghamshire, England. In the late 1960s, initial product development began, soon recognizing mycoprotein's potential as an efficient and nutritious protein source.

If the fact that these alt-chicken cutlets are made up of 51% "vat-grown mold" doesn't affect you, I'm guessing the way they were packaged might:

Here's a better look at the frozen cutlets:

I'll admit it bothers me to constantly have to throw out the plastic that all the alt-patties come in, but I accept it as a necessary evil - for freshness and safety. For Quorn to just throw the cutlets into a cardboard box to become freezer burned and suck up whatever bacteria is in the air is pretty stunning to say the least.

And if that still doesn't give you pause, here is a link to a page on the Center for Science in the Public Interest's website, describing the widespread allergic reactions that mycoprotein has had on Brittons:

CSPI Quorn Complaints

Of course, it's my mission to review all alt-meat products that I can find, so forged ahead anyway and attempted to grill a Naken Chik'n Cutlet.

In the real world, it's pretty hard to grill frozen chicken cutlets. They don't lay flat like burgers do. And the instructions on the box didn't say to thaw the cutlets first, so I attempted to baste it in olive oil and grill it straight out of the box. It wasn't a huge success. No matter how much oil I brushed on, it just wasn't enough. The cutlet never softened, so I just continued to flip the rock-like cutlet until I assumed it was heated all the way through.

I slapped some alt-cheese on top, and oiled up the bun:

I wish I could say that, in the end, the taste of the cutlets offered some ray of hope. But alas, they tasted pretty much how they looked coming out of the box: dry and unappealing.

I guess the silver lining of the whole experience was that I didn't turn out to be one of the 4.5% who is allergic to mycoprotein. And I can say that these cutlets might actually be a decent meat substitute for meals requiring firm tofu, but only if they're basted or marinated with something tasty. On their own, they don't offer much in the way of flavor.

I may tempt fate once more and try grilling another cutlet with barbeque sauce, or I may just count my blessings that I didn't end up with violent diarrhea, numb lips, paralyzed limbs and a fever (all of which are actual symptoms reported in the CSPI article). I won't write Quorn completely off yet, but I may just ditch the other three cutlets and move on to the next Quorn product (which will hopefully be wrapped in some sort of plastic).

Tags: chicken

Boca's Vegan burger

Posted on Feb 9th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Boca
 

There's not much to say about the Boca Vegan patties that I didn't already say in my review of the All American Classic Burger. In a blind taste test, I really doubt that I could tell the difference between the two. And from looking at the ingredient lists of both, it seems all Boca did was remove the (apparently superfluous) egg, milk and cheese from the AACB and came up the Vegan burger.

If you're a "glass is half empty" kind of a person, you'll see this alt-meat patty as just another bland offering from Boca. If you like to view the glass as half full, you'll be happy to know that you can eat a vegan version of the organic All American Classic with no tradeoff in taste. Unfortunately for me, there wasn't much taste to begin with.

Tags: burger

Boca's All American Classic burger

Posted on Feb 6th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Boca
 

It's no secret that I don't like Boca burgers, but I do like the fact that they've released an entire line of organic products. If I'm forced to eat mediocre alt-burgers, at least let them be organic. And so it is with a resigned sigh that I report that the ridiculously-named All American Classic Burger is no different.

Not to get off topic, but what kind of a name is "All American Classic Burger" anyway? Does Boca have an "All Australian" burger? And if they do, can it be also classified as "classic?" Who knows - maybe they even have an "All Irish Postmodern Burger." Ok, enough ranting - back to the burger.

The AACB has the standard fake grilled smokey flavor that is common among alt-burgers, but the patty does differ slightly in taste and texture. The taste and texture hint of a bean paste, despite not having any legumes as ingredients. It wasn't necessarily a bad thing, but nor did it offer any benefit.

Overall, I was happy to know I was eating organic, but the taste would keep me from rushing out to buy more of these ultra-patriotic alt-burgers.

Tags: burger

MorningStar's Philly Cheese Steak burgers

Posted on Feb 6th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
 

I didn't think there was any way that MorningStar could make an alt-philly, but I'll be damned if they didn't do a pretty good job. These patties actually taste kinda like real Philly cheese steaks.

MorningStar could have just taken one of their alt-beef patties, thrown in some green pepper and onion chunks and called it a "Philly chease steak" patty, but these patties do taste distinctly different than the Grillers.

These patties do require a little bit of extra time to prepare. They taste much better fried than they do microwaved. They produce a nice crispy crust that brings the taste a little bit closer to a real Philly cheese steak. And you can't exactly put ketchup and mustard on them (I tried - not a smart idea, FYI) so I had to fry up some onions. What's a Philly without grilled onions? Not a Philly, that's for sure. I soaked the top of the bun in the left-over oil from the frying pan and added a little cheese to the top.

I could almost imagine I was eating a real Philly cheese steak...almost.

Tags: burger

Yves Meatless Smoked Chicken

Posted on Feb 4th, 2008 by Jamie • 
 
Rating:
More info: Yves
 

While these alt-deli slices don't taste exactly like chicken, I did enjoy the taste of them. They have a great blend of spices, and the texture is pretty good. Combined with a slice of alt-cheese (Galaxy Nutritional Foods' Pepper Jack Cheese), some Smart Bacon, and some iceburg, it was quite an enjoyable sandwich.

Tags: deli, chicken
Visit the archive to see older posts.

ABOUT

alt|meat is a blog dedicated to reviewing commercial alternative meat products.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Do you have a product you want alt|meat to review? Drop us an email and let us know what it is (and where we can get it).

FRIENDS OF THE FAMILY

Cool, hip t-shirts for cool, hip guys and gals.
Join players from over 30 countries and play the superchild of Scrabble and Boggle.
Play a new sudoku puzzle online for free every day.
Organize your life with Epigroove's software organizers.
Keep track of your holiday gifts.